Heart Surgery Risk Assessment Tool
Patient Assessment
Answer these questions to determine surgical candidacy based on clinical guidelines
Enter values to see assessment
When doctors talk about heart surgery candidates, the conversation isn’t just about who can benefit-it’s also about who might be harmed. Knowing the red flags helps families avoid unnecessary danger and guides clinicians toward safer alternatives.
Medical Conditions That Form Absolute Contraindications
Some health problems make heart surgery almost impossible because the risk of death outweighs any potential gain.
- Severe Chronic Kidney Disease is a condition where the kidneys function at less than 15% of normal, preventing safe use of cardiopulmonary bypass and increasing postoperative dialysis needs.
- Advanced Pulmonary Hypertension is a dangerous rise in blood pressure within the lung arteries that can cause right‑heart failure during surgery.
- Uncontrolled Infectious Endocarditis is a bacterial infection of heart valves that must be treated with antibiotics before any operation is attempted.
- Severe Aortic Calcification (Porcelain Aorta) is extensive calcium buildup that makes clamping the aorta hazardous and can lead to stone‑wall emboli.
If any of these are present, surgeons usually recommend medical management or less invasive options.
Age, Frailty, and Functional Status
Older age alone isn’t a deal‑breaker, but when it’s combined with frailty, the outlook changes drastically.
- Frailty Syndrome is a clinical syndrome characterized by weakness, slowness, weight loss, and low activity that predicts poor postoperative recovery.
- Reduced Exercise Capacity is often measured by a six‑minute walk test; scores below 300 meters suggest limited ability to withstand surgical stress.
Patients over 80 with a frailty index > 0.35 rarely survive a major open‑heart procedure, so a thorough geriatric assessment is essential before proceeding.
Severe Organ Dysfunction Beyond the Heart
When other vital organs are compromised, the body can’t handle the physiological shock of surgery.
- Advanced Liver Cirrhosis (Child‑Pugh C) is a stage where liver function is so poor that clotting factors are low and bleeding risk skyrockets.
- Severe Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD) is characterized by FEV1 < 30% predicted, making postoperative ventilation weaning extremely difficult.
In such scenarios, less invasive percutaneous interventions (e.g., TAVR, PCI) are often preferred.
Lifestyle and Psychosocial Factors
Even a perfect anatomical case can fail if the patient’s lifestyle won’t support recovery.
- Uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus (HbA1c > 9%) is linked to poor wound healing, higher infection rates, and graft failure.
- Active Substance Abuse is including ongoing alcohol or illicit drug use, which interferes with medication compliance and increases bleeding risk.
- Severe Psychiatric Instability is such as untreated schizophrenia or severe depression, leading to poor postoperative follow‑up.
When these factors are present, surgeons often defer surgery until the patient can achieve better control.
Risk Assessment Tools Used by Cardiac Teams
Doctors rarely rely on gut feeling alone; they use validated scores.
- EuroSCORE II is a model that predicts 30‑day mortality based on age, renal function, left ventricular ejection fraction, and other variables.
- STS Risk Calculator is the Society of Thoracic Surgeons’ tool, providing individualized risks for mortality, stroke, renal failure, and prolonged ventilation.
- Frailty Index is a composite score (gait speed, grip strength, weight loss) that adds a frailty penalty to the baseline surgical risk.
If any calculator predicts a >10% chance of mortality, the team usually explores alternatives first.
Quick Reference Checklist: Who Might Not Be a Good Candidate?
| Contraindication | Type | Typical Impact on Decision |
|---|---|---|
| Severe chronic kidney disease (eGFR <15mL/min) | Absolute | High peri‑operative mortality; dialysis dependence |
| Advanced pulmonary hypertension (PA pressure >55mmHg) | Absolute | Right‑heart failure risk during bypass |
| Frailty index >0.35 | Absolute | Poor functional recovery, high ICU stay |
| Uncontrolled diabetes (HbA1c >9%) | Relative | Infection risk; may be optimized pre‑op |
| Severe COPD (FEV1 <30% predicted) | Relative | Ventilator dependence; consider minimally invasive approach |
| Active substance abuse | Relative | Compliance issues; require rehab before surgery |
When Surgery Might Still Be Considered
Some patients sit in a gray zone. In those cases, a multidisciplinary heart team reviews:
- Potential for symptom relief (e.g., severe angina despite medication)
- Life expectancy from non‑cardiac diseases
- Patient’s personal goals and quality‑of‑life preferences
If the net benefit outweighs the calculated risk, an operation-often using hybrid or catheter‑based techniques-may proceed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can elderly patients ever have heart surgery?
Age alone isn’t a disqualifier. Many patients in their late 70s undergo successful valve replacements, especially when they have good functional capacity and low frailty scores. The decision hinges on a comprehensive geriatric assessment and risk calculator results.
What is the difference between absolute and relative contraindications?
Absolute contraindications mean the risk of death or severe complications is so high that surgery is avoided entirely. Relative contraindications indicate increased risk, but the procedure may proceed if the potential benefit is substantial and the condition can be optimized beforehand.
How do doctors assess frailty before heart surgery?
Common tools include gait speed (walking 5 meters), grip strength via a dynamometer, weight loss over six months, and self‑reported exhaustion. Scores are combined into a frailty index; values above 0.35 usually tip the scale toward non‑surgical management.
Is it possible to reverse a contraindication?
Yes, many are modifiable. For example, improving glycemic control, quitting smoking, treating anemia, or optimizing kidney function with dialysis can shift a relative contraindication to an acceptable risk level.
What alternatives exist for patients who can’t have open‑heart surgery?
Transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR), percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI), minimally invasive mitral repair, and hybrid procedures combining small incisions with catheter‑based techniques are common options.
